
Top Ten Tuesday is a feature hosted by That Artsy Reader Girl. This week’s theme is: Books I Can’t Believe I Read
I thought this would be super easy but I stalled out after… fine, after zero books. So… I cheated, as you do. These are now… Books I Didn’t Believe. Meaning… some part of it simply was not believable. Or plausible. Or likely to happen anywhere in any way. Covers link to Goodreads 😀

Glitter by Aprilynne Pike
Not believable because…. France forcing people to cosplay their lives away? While robots meander around and there are lots of drugs and makeup? That doesn’t make sense. I mean, they aren’t the ones who elect shitty realty television hosts as leaders, so I doubt it.
Inherit Midnight by Kate Kae Myers
Not believable because…. Literally the whole plot.
Hold Me Like a Breath by Tiffany Schmidt
Not believable because…. if you have grown up in a crime family, and were never even allowed to leave your house, you probably know better than to trust freaking randos on the street.
Vivian Versus the Apocalypse by Katie Coyle
Not believable because…. how does all of society jump on board with one creepy church leader? And assume everyone they know has been “raptured”?

100 Hours by Rachel Vincent
Not believable because…. if you are in the middle of a hostage situation in South America, you’re probably thinking less about your crushes and grudges, and more about maybe not being shot.
Graduation Day by Joelle Charbonneau
Not believable because…. Presidents (certain present officials excluded, probably) generally don’t leave the governing and planning up to random sixteen year olds.

Iceling by Sasha Stephenson

Not believable because…. Literal cabbage patch babies. Not like the toy, like actual cabbage.

The Last Girl on Earth by Alexandra Blogier
Not believable because…. Fake gills. Real gills. “Last human ever.” Idk, pick a thing.
The Last Place on Earth by Carol Snow
Not believable because…. Plagues come and go, but Duggars are forever? In seriousness though, plagues last longer than a hot second, nice try. (Also, not kidding, there are the fictional Duggars in this book, and they’re about as likable as the real ones. Which is to say, not at all.)
Fireworks by Katie Cotugno
Not believable because…. out of the literal millions of people who’d want to be in this band, two best friends would be picked? Including one who didn’t even plan to audition? Please.
What are some of the more unbelievable books you have read? Is implausibility a deal breaker for you?
Discover more from It Starts at Midnight
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.



SHANNON, this post is so much fun! Love how you spun this week’s topic. Way to show off that creative side. 🙂
I have “Inherit Midnight” on my shelf, but haven’t read it. When I picked it up, I thought it sounded fun, so we’ll see if I actually put it on my “read” list.
Ha! I love your take on the topic this week. So many books are incredibly unbelievable. I loved reading why they weren’t believable for you.
LOVE your cheat topic!!! I definitely have a few books off the top of my head that could go on this list. Glitter sounds freaking weird as hell!!! I need to look into it. Probably not read it, but I need to read reviews and see what that book is all about because it sounds CRAZY.
I considered adding Vivian Apple #1 to my list, so I smiled when I saw the sequel on your list. I kind of hated that book. My TTT
Cosplay my life away? That is… an interesting premise, I must say. 🙂 And ooh Vivian vs the Apocalypse. I remember that one, I wanted to read it. Pretty dumb huh? And The Last Girl on Earth, because gills *nods*
100 Hours is by Rachel Vincent? Guess I didn’t realize that. I read a book of her last year, and have been wanting to try her Menagerie stuff… that one sounds like a no though.
I second Rissi, love how you did this topic.
Good twist on the topic. Glitter really doesn’t sound too believeable haha. Honestly, they all don’t . 😀
Ooooooooh, this is an amazing way to twist this week’s prompt! I had no idea the new Katie Cotugno novel had that premise, and I’m rolling my eyes just thinking about it – looks like I’ll be avoiding that one despite the extremely beautiful cover. Same with Vivian Versus the Apocalypse: I bought my copy at the library book sale, but that plot sounds really farfetched.
Thank you for saving me from some unbelievable reads!
Here’s my TTT.
I thought Hold Me Like A Breath sounded really cool, but I’ve seen lots of negative stuff about it now, so I think maybe I’ll take it off the TBR!
My TTT: https://jjbookblog.wordpress.com/2018/01/30/top-ten-tuesday-144/
I struggled with the topic this week, and twisted it as well. I love the direction you went with it. I have only read one book on your list, Fireworks, which I guess does seem too serendipitous. I must be honest. I seldom find myself questioning the believability of what I am reading, because I am all about the fiction. So, I think because of that, I have not stored any books in my memory as such. I can think of a few contemporaries, which I thought went too OTT, like The Unlikelies and The Improbable Theory of Ana and Zak, but it’s part of the book I think is unbelievable, not the premise.
Haha great spin on this week’s topic, Shannon! These all sound incredibly unbelievable…
at first glitter seems ridiculous to me too, but after reading it and looking at our current world situation… i wouldn’t be surprised if it happens in the real life! have you read it though?
Vivian Versus the Apocalypse is a great book title, but I agree with you on the premise not being realistic.
Here is our Top Ten Tuesday.
Lol when you put it that way, Glitter really does have a ridiculous premise.
Great list! I haven’t read any of these, but they do sounds unbelievable.
I think you had me at the cabbage patch babies. I almost need to read it just to see how crazy that it! Love your twist and enjoyed seeing why you couldn’t believe these!
I found your blog through TTT Tuesday and I absolutely love it!
Gonna follow right away 😉
I love your spin on the topic! Some of these books sound . . . not good. The Vivian book is on my massive TBR list, though.
I tried reading ‘inherit midnight’ but I was so annoyed with everything, I just couldn’t finish.
I read a lot of fantasy books so I don’t try to believe if something’s possible, more like, if I believe the characters and what they can do.
have a lovely day.
How fun! I can suspend disbelief to an extent, but sometimes it does just become a bit TOO much. I haven’t read any of these, but I doubt I will. haha
-Lauren
I haven’t read any of these, but I’m sad that Inherit Midnight wasn’t great- I love the author, and as another Midnight blogger, I tend to collect books that contain the word Midnight in the title. 😉
I love how you did this weeks topic! I haven’t read any of these books, but definitely think that I am less likely to enjoy a book if it is really unbelievable 🙂
This is such an interesting topic! I never really thought about it but, a lot of books come to mind that, truth be told, weren’t believable or didn’t even make sense. I haven’t read any of the books on your list but, I’ve had my eye on Glitter for some time now but, I might just skip it. It does sound extremely confusing and well, impossible. Not that every Fantasy novel I’ve read this far is believable but, I love Fantasy and when a book is well structured and makes complete sense based on the author’s facts and explanations, I really can’t complain!
LOL at your description of Hold Me Like a Breath! It’s too bad that one was so unbelievable; I’ve been sort of interested in checking it out. 100 Hours also sounds completely eyeroll worthy!
I like Cynical!Shannon. She makes me laugh even more than regular Shannon does. For me, I guess it depends on the tone of the book and the extent to which the novel pushes the realm of possibility. Like, I enjoy some steampunk that has technology in the Victorian era, but a lot of the time, the society is presented as something totally different than what it was. Every once in a while, I stumble on a work that balances invention with accuracy. *Ranting*
I am okay.
*Goes to rant to her cats*
These are all kind of hilarious…in a horrible way? I’m impressed you got through them, lol! The France one made me think of Marie Antoinette on steroids. (The Versailles court was pretty weird back in those days >.>) I think Hold Me Like a Breath is the only one here I’ve read. Lucky for it, it caught me in a good mood, but yes, it was horribly unbelievable if you think about it for a millisecond. XD Great list, Shannon!
This is so fun!! Loved your take on it xD I haven’t read any of these books, but they sound crazy!
UGH didn’t we talk about Seeker being on this post? Who are you? Why don’t you listen to me 😛 But omg Hold Me Like A Breath was just A WILD RIDE. Bruises everywhere.
WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT OF COURSE WE ALL THINK OF OUR CRUSHES AND LOVEY-DOVEY MOMENTS WHEN IN A HOSTAGE SITUATION. ?? Ahem. But in all seriousness, these are hilariously bad and I also love how you did this prompt! I read tons of books where I’m like “lmao as if” and it does spoil the mood a bit. I have no idea why. Currently the book I’m reading, the kid’s parents have sent him overseas to live in a hotel for a month. A MONTH. Like holy heck why is everyone in YA book so loaded…my parents wouldn’t have been able to afford to send me away for a weekend in a tent.??
I like your spin on this topic. The only one of these I’ve read is Vivian, and I agree that it was pretty darn far-fetched. And weird.
Great take on the topic. I haven’t read any of these. Escapist fiction can require us to suspend belief and still be entertaining reading, but even fantasy/dystopian world building needs to be well thought out, and for me at least plausible within the construct presented.
There’s suspension of disbelief and then there’s “you gotta be sh*tting me.” I read one recently where there was NO mention of this character’s “abilities” or special snowflake status and then all of a sudden at the very end, what do you know, it was determined that she was “gifted” and that meant she and the guy could be together. Yay. Puh-leeze. And yeah, in Fireworks the fact that both BFFs made it into the group, when supposedly one didn’t have the talent and wasn’t even going to audition… but hey she had that special something? Pardon me while my eyes roll out of my head.
Great list. I love your take on this week’s topic:) And I enjoyed reading your reasons why you found them unbelievable 😀 Some of these are seriously stupid 😛 I am glad that now I know which one to avoid if I see any of these in future 😀
My TTT: http://flippingthruthepages.com/2018/01/five-famous-book-series-wont-reading-anytime-soon/