The Smaller Evil by Stephanie Kuehn Published by Dutton Books for Young Readers on August 2nd 2016
Pages: 256
Sometimes the greater good requires the smaller evil.
17-year-old Arman Dukoff is struggling with severe anxiety and a history of self-loathing when he arrives at an expensive self-help retreat in the remote hills of Big Sur. He’s taken a huge risk—and two-thousand dollars from his meth-head stepfather—for a chance to "evolve," as Beau, the retreat leader, says.Beau is complicated. A father figure? A cult leader? A con man? Arman's not sure, but more than anyone he's ever met, Beau makes Arman feel something other than what he usually feels—worthless.
The retreat compound is secluded in coastal California mountains among towering redwoods, and when the iron gates close behind him, Arman believes for a moment that he can get better. But the program is a blur of jargon, bizarre rituals, and incomprehensible encounters with a beautiful girl. Arman is certain he's failing everything. But Beau disagrees; he thinks Arman has a bright future—though he never says at what.
And then, in an instant Arman can't believe or totally recall, Beau is gone. Suicide? Or murder? Arman was the only witness and now the compound is getting tense. And maybe dangerous.
As the mysteries and paradoxes multiply and the hints become accusations, Arman must rely on the person he's always trusted the least: himself.


Literally no idea, guys. I am so confused right now. I finished this last night (well, technically early this morning, but shh), and I figured I’d think about it for a bit before writing down my thoughts. But then I realized that I don’t really have any quality thoughts because I have no idea what just happened.
I really enjoyed Stephanie’s Delicate Monsters last year- even though it too had some definite strangeness, I was very intrigued! (You can see my review here- in which I say “this book was messed the hell up”.) And don’t misunderstand, I was incredibly intrigued by The Smaller Evil, too! I just haven’t the vaguest idea what I read.
Here are some plusses about the book, because I assure you, there are plusses:
- The writing is, as I have come to expect from Stephanie Kuehn, extraordinary. Seriously, the writing is so on point. Even when I didn’t know what was happening at all, I just kept wanting to read because the author does such a great job of making the words jump off the page.
- It’s a short and addicting sort of book. I read it in about two hours, and needed to know what was going to happen to Arman- hell, I needed to know what was currently happening to Arman, let’s be honest!
- I really did feel for Arman, even if I wasn’t super connected to him. It was hard to connect to him because the situation he was in was so… bizarre. But the kid had a rough time, and it was easy to sympathize with him, and understand how he’d be in this weird ass place to begin with. And when no one believed Arman, and I wasn’t sure if he was even a reliable narrator, I still rooted for him.
- There’s a cult vibe, and I love a cult vibe. I won’t say anything beyond that (let’s be honest, I couldn’t even if I wanted to), but the feel was definitely eerie and “off”, which is fabulous in this type of book.
- I did understand a bit of the plot, and I liked that particular direction!
The only negative I have for this book is… what even is it!?

And that’s kind of a biggie, really. I actually was pretty convinced that it was just me- maybe I was just missing something? But then I looked at Goodreads, and I don’t think I am alone. That said, maybe someone with a little better ability to think outside the box will have a better grip on this? Like, it is a quick, exciting, and well written book, so I want you all to read it, mostly so someone can figure out what went on.
Bottom Line: I think this should be a team effort, and someone can explain this to me. It wasn’t a bad book at all, and the writing and atmosphere alone make it worth it. But if you don’t like being confused… well, then maybe it won’t work. But if you enjoy a well-written and unique book, this totally fits that bill.

Yes, my rating is a Shrugpony. Because… how?

Have you read a book that leaves you utterly befuddled… yet you still like it in spite of that? I’d love to hear about them!
Discover more from It Starts at Midnight
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


Books that left me befuddled but I still love them – The Raven Boys is definitely one of them. Haha.
Oooh that is a good one! I really enjoyed TRB, but I was a bit lost at times for sure!
OHhhh dear, I HAVE READ BOOKS LIKE THIS. Where you just feel completely befuddle and like you’ve been invited to a conversation and then totally left out of the loop. *sighs* I’m kind of nervous about this one, despite absolutely looooooving this author’s Charm and Strange. Mostly because I don’t like cults? But also being confused is not my favourite.? BUT HER WRITING IS SO SO GOOD so therE’S THAT.
It’s HARD because like- maybe you will “get it”, and maybe there is just something wrong with me? And if that is the case, then YAY. But also, I don’t really think I’m dumb or anything, and I REALLY didn’t get this. But I also have never been one of those people who is good at analyzing literature (I came here to have fun, not to decipher the meaning of life or something) so… maybe it’s me? And all those other people? ?
Oh I hear you. I DO. That’s why I die in the literary ones where it’s all “here read between the lines and this metaphor of soap will solve cancer” and I just….#NOPE. Talk plainly, fiends, or you lose me.
This is how The Graces felt for me! I finished the book and I had a huge question mark floating over my head. The book was good… I think? The writing was pretty good and it seemed like a good plot, but I was just so CONFUSED as to what it was supposed to be! So strange. I feel this.
Oh NO I have to read The Graces like, next basically! This is scary, I cannot handle another one of these ? I am sorry that you felt this way too, it’s never fun!
I read one of Stephanie Kuehn’s other books and wasn’t a fan, though the writing was brilliant. I’m conflicted about reading this one. It sounds interesting, but I don’t want to be disappointed.
I feel you. It’s hard to go into a book knowing it may not work at all. I have only read one of her other books, but if it helps, it prompted me to go buy a few more of her books? So hopefully this is just a “it’s me” situation!
I’m going to be REALLY honest and say I was just as confused reading the book description! Like what is going on?! Thanks for the honest review Shannon!
(I secretly love cultish books as well:)
Bwhahahah right!? The description basically lists all the things I understood about the book after reading- but I still have a billion questions! I have another cult book coming up and I cannot WAIT- I need more cult action 😉
Hahahaha! Those gifs and that rating though.
I’m a mixed bag when it comes to confusing books like this one. On the one hand, I love reading them because they are unique and intriguing, but then on the other hand, I just hate feeling “dumb” if you will.
I have wanted to read something by this author forever though, so I might have to take the plunge one of these days!
And OMG I love cults in books! I think the last one I read was Blood & Salt and I loved that one!
Great review, Shannon!
Hhahah thanks! And SAMEEEE! I don’t generally think I am a stupid human, so when I end up feeling dumb, I get pretty cranky, tbh. And OOOH Blood and Salt is such a good one, I loved it too! If you like cult books, The Sacred Lies of Minnow Bly was pretty great too!
I feel like I’ve seen this cover before but I don’t really know much else about the book (shockingly enough based on your review where no one knows anything about it lol). BUT I do have a tip which I would have done myself if I wasn’t feeling lazy: try to read some professional reviews. They are usually posted on BN or Amazon and often come out early (even before bloggers are reading). I’m not saying they’ll have a better idea but they tend to have to corral their thoughts into a fairly small space and that sometimes leads to more blunt explanations and theories.
Oooh that is a good idea! I should do that! I am GOING to do that! ::Checks Amazon, comes back 5 minutes later::
So. I read those! And they kind of felt how I felt… which makes me feel like maybe I did kind of get it? But THEN that makes me wonder if it’s really “it”? GAH. I also kind of disagree with one of the things that one of the reviewers said completely, actually. Not just on an opinion level either. Hmmm. Now I have to think about this one even more! That is a good thing 😀
Now I really want to read this. I love books that are a bit confusing, it challenges me to think outside the box. Great review, I love those gigs too.
DO ITTTTT! The writing is brilliant, and then we can chat about it! 😀
haha. Thats a great review. To think you found the writing extraordinarily brilliant yet was confused in the end to what happened in the book. I hear you. I have had books like that. But at least the writing was good.
Haha this is too cute, rating is shrugpony. xD I got this one in the mail too, and even the synopsis confused me just a bit. I think I’ll still try to read this one soon, especially for the beautiful writing and to get a good grasp on the main character, maybe I’ll even dissect the book a bit too! Great review <3
A shrugpony rating… that totally needs to be a thing! 🙂 I can tell that this one just is not for me. I don’t always need every question answered and everything tied up with a pretty bow but still… give me something. Come *on*. I’ve read one by Kuehn (Complicit) and gave it 2.5 stars. At the end I felt so manipulated – and annoyed as hell. Granted, I have a problem with unreliable narrators but it wasn’t just that. It just left me cold. I think I’m safe on saying that I should probably avoid Kuehn’s books. Although I’m sure she’s a lovely person and if we every met we would have a nice chai tea latte and braid each other’s hair.
A book that left me utterly befuddled: one comes to mind immediately. Another Little Piece by Kate Karyus Quinn. Have you read that one? OMG, it’s been almost 3 years and I still remember all the WTF moments and finishing it thinking WTH did I just read? That one was beyond twisted.
I think when it comes to books like this, there’s good confusing and there’s bad confusing… and it sounds like this one crossed the line into bad confusing, especially as it doesn’t sound like anything was made clear in the end. I am kind of curious though… this might be one I end up borrowing from the library!
Here is all you need to know about this book.
I AM THE BIGGER EVIL. BECAUSE I AM BIGGER. AND EVIL. Maybe my best friend is the smaller evil? Though she is more adorable than evil and I love her.
But in all seriousness, shrugpony <3
I love the shrugpony. Meanwhile I always hate when I look at a book and go WT–? What did I just read? I love being challenged by a book but if I’m still as unenlightened at the end and more confused than when I started ?? Nope. I’m not smart enough for that.
The Square Root of Summer was like this a bit, especially the time travel science bit, but the rest of it, the relationships between the main character and her grandfather, was excellent. So it was a bit of a mixed bag of confusion and really good story. This one sounds like it definitely had its good moments, but so frustrating!
This type of book just makes me twitchy – I can’t handle books that make no sense. Guess I’ll skip this one!
Everyone I know is so confused by this book! I’m tempted to pick up this one to see what I think of it, but I also don’t want to think too hard, if you know what I mean :P. I READ FOR FUN. Not to exercise my literary muscles.
I am superbly curious about this one now! I have recently read The Gargoyle by Andrew Davidson, and I’m still not quite sure I know what I was reading about, but I know that the book was amazing and it mesmerized me. Not sure how or why, but it was just…. amazing. It’s the weirdest thing ever!