
I have things to say about these books! You may wonder about what I have to say about these books! I bring you them in a tasty, bite-sized snack, much more satisfying that those silly one-bite Snickers. There’s nothing fun about skimping on chocolate.
The Night We Said Yes by Lauren Gibaldi
The Witch Hunter by Virginia Boecker
Extraordinary Means by Robyn Schneider
The Night We Said Yes by Lauren Gibaldi
Goodreads | Amazon | Book Depository
Pages: 304
Format: eARC
Published June 16th 2015 by Harper Teen
Source: Copy provided from publisher for review, via Edelweiss
A fun, romantic read, perfect for fans of Sarah Dessen and Susane Colasanti!
Before Matt, Ella had a plan. Get over a no-good ex-boyfriend. Graduate from high school without any more distractions. Move away from Orlando, Florida, where she’s lived her entire life.
But Matt—the cute, shy, bespectacled bass player who just moved to town—was never part of that plan.
And neither was attending a party that was crashed by the cops just minutes after they arrived. Or spending an entire night saying “yes” to every crazy, fun thing they could think of.
Then Matt abruptly left town, and he broke not only Ella’s heart but those of their best friends, too. So when he shows up a year later with a plan of his own—to relive the night that brought them together—Ella isn’t sure whether Matt’s worth a second chance. Or if re-creating the past can help them create a different future.
In alternating then and now chapters, debut author Lauren Gibaldi crafts a charming, romantic story of first loves, lifelong friendships, uncovered secrets, and, ultimately, finding out how to be brave.

Things with this book started off pretty decently. I was into the story of Ella’s relationship with Matt, where he vanished to, what the mystery was, and of course, if they were going to end up together. But there were some things along the way that really interfered with my liking of this book.
Things I liked:
- Even though it is told in one (technically two, with flashbacks) night, it really worked. I never felt like I was bored with the pace, nor did I feel anything was rushed. I also really liked the way the flashbacks were integrated throughout the story.
- Some of Ella and Matt’s “first night” were really cute. I liked that they were a bit shy and awkward, and basically banded together while Jake and Meg were being ridiculous.
- I did like that Meg was trying to keep Ella from getting hurt again, and trying to be a really good friend. I feel like there is never enough of that in books!
Things I didn’t:
- Parent-in-YA Syndrome is real in this book. Seriously, do these people have parents, or were they straight up raised by wolves? Look, I get that they’re on the precipice of leaving for college and all that jazz, and maybe I am just being naive, but my parents went crazy on me when I was 18 (and already in college) and was eating Rita’s Italian Ice in a friend’s driveway too late. These kids are just running all over the town on multiple nights getting into all kinds of shenanigans, and nary a parent cares.
- Matt’s big “revelation” kind of underwhelmed me. I mean, clearly I cannot say much, but it just didn’t make enough sense for me. I don’t know what I was expecting, but it just was something more I guess. Not that we knew a ton about Matt, but it seems like he is pretty good at lame excuses and not knowing how to behave like a human, so I guess maybe it makes sense? Speaking of…
- The characters fell a bit flat for me. I didn’t know much about Ella except that she liked Matt and likes to write. As for the supporting characters, I felt nothing. There was a lot of arguing between Ella’s friends Meg and Jake, who were in a super toxic relationship. Everyone was mad at everyone at some point, and it got old, fast. They also had very little personality, and I found my mind wandering, wondering what on earth these people could find to talk to each other about during the other 364 days of the year.
- Ella and Matt were kind of insta-lovey. Not insta-love, exactly, let’s call it insta-relationship. I mean, they were fairly serious after one night, which is a bit strange. Maybe I could have seen it had they known each other before that night but… they did not.
Bottom Line: I mean, I didn’t hate this book. I adored the concept, and even the execution in regards to the flashbacks and such. I would definitely give the author another try, as the writing and ideas were fine, but in a character driven novel where you know little about the characters and what you do know you do not like… well, you get the idea.

The Witch Hunter by Virginia Boecker
Goodreads
| Amazon | Book Depository
Pages: 385
Format: eARC/BEA
Published June 2nd 2015 by Little, Brown Books for Young Readers
Source: Copy provided from publisher for review, via Netgalley/ Copy provided from publisher at BEA
The magic and suspense of Graceling meet the political intrigue and unrest of Game of Thrones in this riveting fantasy debut.
Your greatest enemy isn’t what you fight, but what you fear.
Elizabeth Grey is one of the king’s best witch hunters, devoted to rooting out witchcraft and doling out justice. But when she’s accused of being a witch herself, Elizabeth is arrested and sentenced to burn at the stake.
Salvation comes from a man she thought was her enemy. Nicholas Perevil, the most powerful and dangerous wizard in the kingdom, offers her a deal: he will save her from execution if she can break the deadly curse that’s been laid upon him.
But Nicholas and his followers know nothing of Elizabeth’s witch hunting past–if they find out, the stake will be the least of her worries. And as she’s thrust into the magical world of witches, ghosts, pirates, and one all-too-handsome healer, Elizabeth is forced to redefine her ideas of right and wrong, of friends and enemies, and of love and hate.
Virginia Boecker weaves a riveting tale of magic, betrayal, and sacrifice in this unforgettable fantasy debut.

Ooooh this book. My sadness knows no bounds. I wanted to love it, goodness, I did! I mean, it’s witch hunting! How could that possibly go wrong?
So, I made it to 52%, which is pretty good, no? And I am very hesitant to DNF, so you know it isn’t a decision I took lightly. Basically, I could not get into this book, and I found myself caring exactly zero percent about what happened. I knew I was just forcing myself to finish, and that would be a mistake. A few things that I pinpointed that led to my decision:
1. It didn’t feel like the book took place in the past. I felt like the setting could have absolutely been today, a hundred years from now, in the third century B.C., whenever! There was nothing that made me feel like it was a historical setting, which bummed me out.
2. Elizabeth made me sleepy. I just could not with her. She was so boring. I didn’t care at all if she hunted witches, ate witches, became a witch, looked like a witch, slept with a witch… you see where this is going.
3. The love interest(s?) were equally mind-numbing. See, there was this one really crappy dude in the beginning, I did not like him, but Elizabeth did, apparently. I was pretty sure I knew who the second one would be (yep, triangle time!) and apparently I was right. Maybe Dude #2 got better as the story went on, but again, there was so much lack of caring by that point.
4. I was straight up bored of the plot. It just seemed… generic. I think that came off harsher than I meant it to, but there was just nothing about it that held my interest. I just felt like I’d read similar stuff before and since I didn’t care about anyone in the story, the world it was set in, or the plot… well, it didn’t make sense to drive myself nuts any longer.
Bottom Line: I do know people who really liked this book, so it may be a win for you. It was just very much not one for me.

Extraordinary Means by Robyn Schneider
Goodreads
| Amazon | Book Depository
Pages: 336
Format: eARC
Published May 26th 2015 by Katherine Tegen Books
Source: Copy provided from publisher for review via Edelweiss
From the author of The Beginning of Everything: two teens with a deadly disease fall in love on the brink of a cure.
At seventeen, overachieving Lane finds himself at Latham House, a sanatorium for teens suffering from an incurable strain of tuberculosis. Part hospital and part boarding school, Latham is a place of endless rules and confusing rituals, where it’s easier to fail breakfast than it is to flunk French.
There, Lane encounters a girl he knew years ago. Instead of the shy loner he remembers, Sadie has transformed. At Latham, she is sarcastic, fearless, and utterly compelling. Her friends, a group of eccentric troublemakers, fascinate Lane, who has never stepped out of bounds his whole life. And as he gradually becomes one of them, Sadie shows him their secrets: how to steal internet, how to sneak into town, and how to disable the med sensors they must wear at all times.
But there are consequences to having secrets, particularly at Latham House. And as Lane and Sadie begin to fall in love and their group begins to fall sicker, their insular world threatens to come crashing down.
Told in alternating points of view, Extraordinary Means is a darkly funny story about doomed friendships, first love, and the rare miracle of second chances.

This is a hard book to review. There were parts of it that I loved so, so much. First, just the premise is so fabulous. A resurgence of tuberculosis, a sanitarium full of kids? Fabulous! And the characters, oh, I adored the characters! Not just Lane and Sadie (the book is told from their dual POVs) but their gang of friends too. Actually, not even just their gang of friends, even the random weird kids interjected into the book were so fun and well developed in their own rights.
And there were feels, obviously, but not just tearful ones. No, there was a lot of fun, and humor, and this disturbing feeling that you kind of wanted TB just so you could hang out with this group at Latham House. And yes, of course there was the sadness and fear that comes along with a bunch of kids trying to cope with a grave illness at an age where they are already experiencing enough upheaval. The relationships among all the characters were really great too, I loved that there were times when the boys would just hang out together and the girls would do the same, they didn’t always have to be attached, but they did have more fun when they were!
So, what is the problem? Well, it’s twofold: First, it was a bit predictable for me. I knew what was going to happen, and I didn’t want it to, but I did. Second, there were a ton of pop culture/current technology references. I understand that the author wanted us to know that this was contemporary, but in doing so, it really dates the book. I mean, in six months kids won’t even be talking about the same phone, the same movies, etc., and too many current references have a tendency to grate on me for some reason.
Bottom Line: The concept and characters were an absolute win for me. The plot was a bit formulaic, but the bones of the story were very well done, and I enjoyed the journey and the emotions of the characters at Latham.
So, there you have it! Have you read any of these? Thoughts?
And would you ever take the challenge of saying “yes” to everything, just for one night?
Discover more from It Starts at Midnight
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.



As someone who managed to finish Witch Hunter, I can tell you that you didn’t miss much.
I think the last 10 or so pages were the only ones I actually enjoyed…but, yeah, wasn’t really worth finishing, in my opinion.
I mean, yeah, some people loved it, but it definitely wasn’t for me. We seem to have similar opinions of it.
Bwahha that is good to know! Another blogger said the same, so I am just taking both of your words for it 😉 Maybe I will just read the last 10 pages! Sorry it didn’t work out for you either though 🙁
I’ve read unenthusiastic reviews about “The night we said yes”, but I’d never heard about the others 😉
Well… that might be for the best 😉 Extraordinary Means wasn’t bad, I liked it for the most part! But you could get away with skipping The Witch Hunter and be very happy 😀
I like the sound of the flashbacks and mystery of The Night we Said Yes, but the parents not caring what the teenagers were up to would bother me as well. And the characters sound kind of flat.
Such a shame about the Witch Hunter, I’ve heard so many negative reviews of it now that I’ve taken it off my TBR!
I have Extraordinary Means on my TBR list and I’m looking forward to it, even though you know what’s going to happen.
Great reviews!
The characters were definitely flat, and yeah- I mean, one absent parent, maybe. FOUR absent parents!? Come on. And none of them were like, from high-risk situations, so it made no sense!
Honestly, good call on The Witch Hunter. I was SO sad. This is quite possibly the most let down I have been by a book I was really looking forward to.
And Extraordinary Means is totally worth the read! I hope you enjoy it!
I want to read The Night We Said Yes and Extraordinary Means. I have really only read really good things about the Night We Said Yes so it is nice to see a little different view. I laughed at the YA Parent Syndrome. It is so true though. And I could never say yes for an entire night. I feel like as a parent I am now conditioned to say no (No YA Parent Syndrome here!)
I agree, I have seen a LOT of glowing reviews lately about TNWSY, but I do know of a few people who’ve also disliked it (some VERY much so), but I think more people than not do like it. I would want to do it- say yes. Even as a parent- but you know, as long as the kids were tucked safely into bed elsewhere 😉
Hi Shannon – Wanted to let you know that I nominated y’all for a blogger award. (It’s basically a tag, as I just learned.) Here’s a link to the post so you can join in if you’d like: http://girlplusbooks.blogspot.com/2015/06/beautiful-blogger-award.html
Aww thank you so much!! That is really nice! I do love a tag 😀
I was intrigued by The Night We Said Yes by the book trailer. But the comparison to Sarah Dessen left me a little cold (I’m not a fan). After reading your review I might just give it a pass. I’m much more excited about Extraordinary Means! I’m really looking forward to that one.
Ah, that makes sense! I don’t really think it is comparable to Sarah Dessen but… in a bad way. If that makes sense? Either way, you’re probably making the right call 😉 Also, Extraordinary Means is good! That one has a LOT more emotion and substance! Hope you enjoy it!
I had similar feelings about The Witch Hunter except that I gave up on it way earlier than you did. It’s been interesting following its reception closer to the release. After I decided to give up on it, I started noticing a lot more middling or DNF reviews.
Good call on the early DNF! I wish I hadn’t forced myself. I honestly knew around 20% that it wasn’t happening, but I just wanted it to so badly, I guess! It’s a shame 🙁
Yeah…I didn’t really like The Night We Said Yes at all, mainly because I just didn’t feel anything at all for the characters, the writing, the romance, just nope. Nothing. Kind of annoyed me in places though. Yup, Parent-In-YA Syndrome indeed (and it is definitely catching on!) 😉 Yeah, I really expected something really bad or important for why Matt left. Ha! Those bits where it annoyed me, was definitely the friendships, I just, okay, at times Ella and Meg seemed like friends, but most of the time they just seemed like they tolerated one another. And don’t even get me started on Meg and Jakes relationship. And Ella and Matt’s. Just nope.
Haha! The Witch Hunter was definitely boring. Really boring. Like boring boring. And I just loved how much the witch hunters were hypocrites, so there’s a twist (I can’t remember if it’s revealed where you left it) but I was like…really, you didn’t figure that out sooner, guys? Come on.
I was so for the first half of Extraordinary Means, really, I was, but then I got so annoyed with Sadie, and I really didn’t like how they went out and no only endangering their own lives, but others too, so didn’t really care about that ending.
I would like to say yes, that I would say yes, but that would be a lie. I guess it depending on who I was with.
That was how I felt too- and I mean, on one hand, I DO understand that we cannot know ALL the things about them in one (but really two) nights, but there still should have been SOME emotion behind them. Yawn.
And The Witch Hunter… ugh. I am so glad I DNFed that. Did you finish it? I am going to have to check your review, if you did one! (Off to look now, of course!) because I hated that book. You know I never DNF, so it HAD to be bad!
And I DO get what you mean about Sadie. On one hand, I guess I understood, because she’d been there for SO long, plus she was just a kid, not thinking about the ramifications. But then on the other hand… that dude and his kids! But then what happened… yeah. I don’t know. I just don’t know.
I kind of had a feeling I would not like The Night We Said Yes too much. I guess it seems a little too contemporary for me. Does that even make sense. I kind of like darker YA contemporary more than the lighter ones. And I am so disappointed that you couldn’t finish The Witch Hunter. I actually read another review that was not favorable either. Your review cinches it. I will skip that one.
YES! I agree 100%- too… cookie cutter contemp, I guess is the way I’d describe it! Larissa @ YA Midnight Reads posted THE best review ever of this book, let me find it- http://yamidnightreads.com/2015/05/review-the-night-we-said-yes-by-lauren-gibaldi/ Seriously, this may be one of my favorite reviews of ALL time. It is hilarious, and sadly, totally accurate!
The Witch HUnter was just so boring for me. And it is only the 3rd book I have EVER DNFed which I think says a lot 😉 Skipping it is probably a very good call!
LOL at your Witch Hunter review. You honestly did not miss out on much, the last couple of chapters were the best in the book, but overall it is a terrible book. I won’t be continuing with the series either, It’s a shame because the cover was gorgeous and the premise actually was really interesting .. Love the honest reviews though 🙂
I love bite size reviews! =)
So, I technically didn’t read Witch Hunter, I DNF’d it and I didn’t even make it as far as you did. It was one of those for me where right away I hated the main character and I just knew I would not enjoy the book, plus I was already book slumping I couldn’t handle reading one I wasn’t liking!
I really liked Night We Said Yes, especially the side characters, I kind of thought it would’ve been more interesting if Meg and Jake were the main characters, honestly. But it was fun and fluffy and I like fun and fluffy. Matt and Ella both fell a little flat for me too though and the big reveal, what was the point? It wasn’t even that big of a thing, it just seemed kind of childish. I was also expecting more excitement from the whole saying yes thing, like they didn’t even do anything that crazy, they got drunk, went almost skinny dipping, kissed, Ella sang. Like where’s the grand adventure I was expecting?
Great reviews, Shannon! =)
Your reading seems to be a bit up and down just like it was for me. When I first heard of The Night We Said, I was kind of excited to pick it up. The concept sounding cool, and I always like the idea of a story going from past to present. But then the reviews started rolling in, and they were so freaking mixed, that I decided to change my mind. I’ve been in a shitty reading funk, so I’m apprehensive about ANY book these days. I agree about parents in YA, why aren’t they more involved in their children’s lives? It would be quite realistic being that my mother was on me about even talking to boys on the phone at that age! lol. I’ve heard the same reactions to Witch Hunter which immediately turned me off, and I’m still on the fence about Extraordinary Means.