So, these are both sci-fi books about, you guessed it, troubles in space! What happens when your ship begins to die? How about when every adult dies, and then some of your peers, too? I mean, disasters on Earth are bad enough, take it to space and you have a lot more trouble! Oh, and good news, I liked them both! 
This Splintered Silence by Kayla Olson
Published by HarperTeen on November 13, 2018
Pages: 368
Format:eARC
Source:Copy provided by publisher for review, via Edelweiss
GoodreadsAmazonBook Depository

Lindley Hamilton has been the leader of the space station Lusca since every first-generation crew member on board, including her mother, the commander, were killed by a deadly virus.

Lindley always assumed she’d captain the Lusca one day, but she never thought that day would come so soon. And she never thought it would be like this—struggling to survive every day, learning how to keep the Lusca running, figuring out how to communicate with Earth, making sure they don’t run out of food.

When a member of the surviving second generation dies from symptoms that look just like the deadly virus, though, Lindley feels her world shrinking even smaller. The disease was supposed to be over; the second generation was supposed to be immune. But as more people die, Lindley must face the terrifying reality that either the virus has mutated or something worse is happening: one of their own is a killer.

This was quite a fun book! While not perfect, I found it to be quite enjoyable and I was certainly invested in the mystery aspect of the story. Let’s break it down into likes/dislikes, because I cannot really talk about the plot too much for fear of spoiling!

The Stuff I Liked:

  • It was incredibly entertaining. Despite any other flaws, I just plain really liked the story. Is it murder? Is it a virus mutation? Something else? I am not telling obviously, but you get the idea- there are a lot of possibilities. Which keeps the reader engaged, as you’d imagine. And while I thought I might have figured it out a few times, I didn’t actually until much later.
  • The explanations seemed legit. I mean, okay, I don’t actually know from a scientific perspective because I am not some kind of… space biologist or something. But to my common sense it sounded reasonable. And really, that is all I need. Sometimes in the “adults are gone” shtick, the reasons are… suspect at best. Here, that isn’t the case.
  • I really felt for Lindley and the other characters. Can you imagine all the adults just dying over a few week period? Because it sounds awful. Not only do you have to figure everything out on your own, but you have to deal with a crap ton of emotions while you’re doing it. Then throw in dead friends and well, it’s not a great scenario.
  • The stakes are crazy high. I mean, they’re in space by themselves with who knows what killing them. I don’t actually think stakes get much higher, as a rule?

The Stuff I Didn’t:

  • Especially at first (but really throughout the thing) I had a hard time keeping track of who’s who. Lindley is the main character, and narrator. And we spend a ton of time in her head, obviously. And she does spend time with other characters, but there are just so many of them. Even her “inner circle” is six people, and man, I had trouble keeping them straight.
  • The romance situation is a veritable Gale-Katniss-Peeta love triangle. But where the aforementioned triangle added something to the story, I didn’t feel like this one did. I didn’t really care who, if anyone, she ended up with, though I didn’t dislike either guy either.

Bottom Line: Super entertaining and full of action and mystery, it’s definitely worth checking out if you’re a sci-fi fan!


Toxic by Lydia Kang
Published by Entangled: Teen on November 6, 2018
Pages: 368
Format:eARC
Source:Copy provided by publisher for review, via Netgalley
GoodreadsAmazonBook Depository

Cyclo, the first and largest biological ship of its kind, is dying. A small crew of mercenaries have handed over the rights to their life to document the death of the ship, but the abandoned ship is anything but abandoned―one girl has been left behind.

Hana has known nothing but the isolation of a single room and the secret that has kept her there for seventeen years. When she meets Fennec, the boy assigned to watch her, she realizes that there is a world she has yet to experience but she is doomed to never meet.

When crew members begin mysteriously dying, Hana and Fenn realize that they are racing against the death of the ship to find a way to survive―unless someone kills them even before Hana’s truly had a chance to live.

I have read a few books about sentient spaceships, and my favorite thing about this is that it seemed like a fresh take on sentient ships. Our girl Hana wakes up to find that she’s all alone. Her mom, and everyone else on the ship she lived on, are gone. Only, Hana has never been out of her family’s quarters before, because oopsie, she’s a secret.

Enter Fenn and his crew, who have taken this one-way trip to Cyclo ship to find out why it is dying. Their mission is to collect all the data they can, and literally go down with the ship. In return, their families might get some money (but probably not because clearly this mission is not on the up-and-up). My one qualm with the book is that Hana acclimates to other people a little more quickly than I’d have thought. I expected a bit more awkwardness, a bit more… social inappropriateness, I suppose. But instead, she finds love in a hopeless place (sing it with me!) and at first I was skeptical because it is a little insta-lovey? But I guess it makes sense. She’s never seen a human dude before, and he thinks he’s about to die so… why not, right?

It gets pretty intense as the crew races against time and a dying ship to try to save themselves. But then stuff goes…. off the rails. And that is about all I can say about that. It’s definitely high stakes, I really never felt like either main character was safe- and certainly no one else was. There are lots of secrets to uncover, and mysteries to solve, and I was absolutely invested in both the characters and the story itself. 

Bottom Line: Quite an enjoyable ride with sympathetic characters and a really unique sentient ship story. Definitely recommend!

SO let’s talk space: Would you ever board a ship to head out for the unknown? Especially if you knew your whole life would be spent on it? Does the thought high key terrify you like it does me?

Posted November 8, 2018 by Shannon @ It Starts at Midnight in Dual, Review / 16 Comments


16 responses to “Dual Review: Troubles in Space

  1. Omg space TERRIFIES ME no thank you. It’s that whole being in a box thing with no escape.😂Take those flying coffins away from me. (Come to think of it, this is probably why I don’t gravitate to sci-fi. Also I have bery bad lucky and would absolutely end up on an Illuminae sort of ship and DIE.) anyway!! I do want to read something by Lydia Kang though and I loveee the idea of a sentient ship.😍

    • YES that is exactly how I feel! Like if you are on Earth and shit hits the fan… you can run or hide or Idk whatever! But in space…. where do you GO?! Nowhere you just die. I still love reading and watching sci-fi stuff. And let’s be real, I don’t think I’d even turn down a free space trip, but I would be TERRIFIED the entire time.

  2. I’m glad you liked them! For some reason, I don’t read a lot of sci-fi, which is weird because I usually like it. I’m fascinated with space, but allowing me to go there would probably be a terrible idea. Having to stay in a spaceship for years would make me crazy.

  3. Uh no, I will *not* be boarding any space-bound ships. No ma’am. I love how Cait refers to the as flying coffins. That about sums it up.

    This Splintered Silence is giving me serious Across the Universe vibes. The whole crew members dying, young person taking over, possible sinister plot at work… but it’s been lighter years (see what I did there?) since I read that one so I could be way off base.

    • Ooooh I own Across the Universe but have never read it, now I am VERY curious. (Bwhahah LOVE the pun!)

      Seriously though, have you ever read/watched a space story that just ends with everyone LIVING? No, you have not. Everyone dies.

  4. So This Splintered Silence sounds right up my alley, and considering my thoughts on The Expanse this is probably a no- brainer. 🙂 And a sentient ship? That sounds kinda wild. Plus 4 stars! Wow the SF just keeps rolling, doesn’t it? There has been SO much good SF this year…

    • Yes, TSS had a similar vibe to The Expanse actually- like that feeling of “well shit this isn’t going to end well” but of course, to a lesser extent because you figure someone will live, it’s YA. Also, fewer glowing blue people.

      The sentient ship take is interestinG! Different than others I have read. In a lot of them the ships are cooperative, and this one is… less so. And the thing is dying, which I have NEVER read about before. So definitely an interesting take! They were both pretty entertaining, if not completely mind-blowing!

  5. I’m dying to read Toxic (as well as Kang’s The November Girl). I’m not fond of insta-love, but it seems to make sense for Hanna to fall in love so fast since she never saw a guy before and they may all die. Thanks for sharing your review.

    Happy readings!;)

  6. I would TOTALLY get on a ship and go out into space for a long duration. That sounds amazing. But then, I’ve been a scifi fan my whole life, so it’s something I’ve thought about for years. I’m reading The Long Way to a Small Angry Planet right now, and it fits into your theme. Jumping through the galaxy on a patched-together ship sounds like fun.

  7. Okay, so I have a highly irrational fear of outer space. Like, I don’t want to even think about it, so I avoid MOST books that are set in space. lol I’m glad that you enjoyed both of these for the most part though!!!

Leave a Reply